• Second Reading


[3.31 p.m.]

Ms ARMITAGE (Launceston) - Mr President, I too thank the Leader for the briefing. It was very good and we found out quite a lot about Metro we did not know.

I support this bill in principle and accept that opening up the options for Metro to other services, including ferries and perhaps trains, in the future is sensible because long-term planning is critical. I note the bill removes the restriction on the type of passenger service Metro can provide.

I also accept Metro will establish a demand analysis. However, it is important we have a fair playing field for all operators. While I accept the plan is for Metro to operate a ferry from Bellerive to Hobart, I would be concerned if it then started to compete with private operators on existing routes, given its government assistance. I note that in 2016-17, the Metro loss after tax was $2.12 million.

Mr Valentine - Not loss, cost. Sorry, that is one of my pet hates.

Ms ARMITAGE - That is quite all right. I have many pet hates and many of them are to do with Metro. Many of them come from my local council days and I have had many discussions with Metro about lack of routes and lack of services.

Ms Rattray - And the bus shelters and where they locate them. That was a big one.

Ms ARMITAGE - I have not heard that one.

Ms Rattray - Okay, you were not on the St John Street one.

Ms ARMITAGE - There is more to that, so I will not delve there. While I appreciate it is nothing to do with this bill and this is purely about allowing Metro to operate ferries, I would also like to see a tender process for a service such as Bellerive to Hobart or other services that might be proposed in the future. It is all about a fair playing field, particularly for private enterprise.

There are areas of the state where it is more about the need for transport rather than profitability. I have concerns when private enterprise is seriously disadvantaged by government or council organisations, and we have all seen such situations.

We accept traffic is getting to be a greater problem on our roads and good public transport can certainly assist with that. I have had many issues with Metro over a long time, particularly about the lack of services in some area of Launceston. It is hard to use something that does not exist.

I have been told on many occasions that the service would be increased if people used it more. As I pointed out, if the service is not there, people cannot use it. It is very hard to use a service more if it actually does not exist and that is the case in some areas.

Mr Valentine - Chicken and egg.

Ms ARMITAGE - Yes, it is a chicken and egg problem, and I am not sure how we go about fixing that.

As other members mentioned - and it might have been the member for Windermere from the sidelines - with regard to parking, it needs to be provided at a free or nominal cost. If people are going to use the ferry, they need to be able to park. They do not want a large parking fee and then their ferry cost and then something else. It makes it difficult. I certainly support this Metro Tasmania 'and miscellaneous' amendment bill. Perhaps the -

Mr Valentine - Move an amendment to change the title.

Ms ARMITAGE - I think the title of the bill is misleading because it is about more than Metro. We have had much discussion about this legislation and many issues have been covered. I certainly will support the bill. I am concerned that there will be a fair playing field and I certainly expect the Government will ensure that will be the case.

Having said that, one member mentioned that a ferry on the Tamar might be a cheaper option.

Mr Dean - A ferry on the Tamar could have legs; it could walk.

Ms ARMITAGE - Depending upon the time of the tide.

Mr Valentine - There are ferries on the Tamar now.

Ms ARMITAGE - There are, but not for transporting people. It might be a cheaper option for the Government, rather than proposing the bridge in a 10-year time frame, just to have a ferry going across to the other side of the Tamar. Maybe that is something they can think about.

I support the bill.


Recent Posts

See All

Benefits of dancing

Mr President, Today I wish to speak about some of the issues that many elderly people in my electorate are experiencing. It is widely accepted that looking after ourselves and keeping healthy means mo

Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill

Ms ARMITAGE (Launceston) - Ms ARMITAGE (Launceston) - Mr President, I commend the member for Mersey for all the work he has done on this bill and the commitment he has made to voluntary assisted dyin



M | 0419 341 178
EMAIL Rosemary


Ground Floor, Henty House

One Civic Square

Launceston 7250


Electorate Office


T | (03) 6324 2000

F | (03) 6324 2008

Parliament House


T | (03) 6212 2353

F | (03) 6231 1849

© 2020 Rosemary Armitage MLC

  • Join our Facebook